Allah in the Quran, Chapter 64

 

Chapter 64

GUIDANCE IS FROM ALLAH

 

001 This claim is very clearly and often repeated in the Quran - and by Islam. But like all other central claims in the Quran, not one valid proof for the claim is provided. Remember here that "a proof is one or more proved facts which can give only one conclusion".

002 Also remember: "A claim without a proof may be dismissed without a proof".

003 And: "The whole next life is too serious a question to build only on lose statements and as lose claims - and especially when they only are built on the words of a man with a morality and reliability like the real Muhammad". (The glossy picture Islam and Muslims paint of Muhammad, has very little to do with the real Muhammad. Read Islamic history - but with your brain and not only your eyes and ears engaged - and judge for yourself.)

004 And then there is the fact that the Quran is not from any god - no god would deliver a book of that quality. It simply is slander and impiety and heresy and an insult to a god, to blame all those errors, contradictions, cases of invalid logic, cases of helpless information/explanation, etc. on him/her. And as the Quran is not from any god, also its guidance is not from a god. Then from who?

005 There only remain the 3 famous or infamous possibilities:

  1. A. The dark forces. A lot of the texts in the Quran may indicate this, as a lot of the texts fit the dark forces better than they fit a claimed good and benevolent god. Compare MANY points in the Quran to f.x. "do to others like you want others do to you", and judge for yourself.
  2. B. A mental illness - likely TLE (Temporal Lobe Epilepsy). Modern medical science suspects this, and Muhammad's fits and religious "experiences" fit that illness very well.
  3. C. A cold and scheming human brain - f.x. Muhammad's.

Or a combination of these. F.x. modern science tends to believe that Muhammad may have believed in his own words in the beginning, but that he later lost this belief, became cynical to his religion, and more and more used his religious tales and claims as tools for personal gain an power - and more and more so as he was morally destroyed by his success and power. Few experiences can destroy a person like success and power. (This "picture may indicate onset of f.x. TLE, and not understanding what happened, he in the beginning believed in his 'religious experiences' - such "religious Experiences" are quite normal for persons with TLE. Then as he gradually understood the reality, his self-centeredness and cynicism took over".)

Personally we are doubtful to alternative A because not even a devil would deliver a "holy" book of that quality, if he meant to lure people his way. He had to know the book had to be seen through sooner or later and lose its credibility. But of course he may have been forced to by a god wanting to give people a reasonable chance to discover the deception.

Personally we tend to agree with science: The most likely deliverer of the Quran was a man working out from a combination of points B and C.

And in that case also the advices in the book were from that man and from those guiding lines.

Are the brutality, discrimination, and selfishness Islam and its moral code build on, satisfying for modern cultures and societies? - or for you and me?

We must admit that the Quran's populist moral code is much easier and tempting to live up to than "do to others like you want others do to you". But it also is easy to see why the Muslim culture and powers stagnated and petrified (luckily - what had the world looked like today if f.x. the industrial revolution with its better weapons and large "muscles" had happened in the Muslim area?).

006 16/107b: "- - - Allah will not guide those who reject Faith". But is he able to guide at all?

  1. There has been no proof for even Allah's existence.
  2. There has been no proof for that he in case was/is a god.
  3. There has been no proof for his claimed power.
  4. There has been no proof for that he ever guided anyone, included Muhammad.
  5. There has been no proof for his claimed connection to Muhammad.
  6. There has been no proof for his claimed benevolence. On the contrary he is a god of war and discrimination, if he exists.
  7. There are solid proofs for that he has no connection to the Quran - no god would deliver that quality "guide-book" - unbelievable 3ooo+ errors, etc. + low quality literature.
  8. There are solid proofs for lots of mistakes, etc. (3ooo+) in the Quran = no reliable "guide-book".
  9. There are solid proofs for hundreds of points with wrong facts in the Quran.
  10. The many errors in the Quran are 100% proof for that the book is not from any god.
  11. There are solid proofs for that the Bible is not falsified - science + for OT Jesus/the Qumran scrolls, and not least Islam, who has found not one proved falsification in the entire Bible. There are some errors also in the Bible, but neither science nor Islam has found even one proved falsification.
  12. The Quran's partly immoral moral code is a solid proof for that no good or benevolent god is involved.
  13. The many and fundamental differences in Yahweh's and Allah's teachings, moral codes, etc. are 100% and more proofs for that the two are not the same god - and Jesus and Muhammad not in the same religion.
  14. The surahs from Medina are solid proofs for that Islam is a religion of war, dishonesty, and apartheid.

Finally: Always when you read the Quran, Hadiths, and other Islamic books, you should remember that Muhammad accepted the use of and himself used dishonesty in many forms in words and deeds. Even if the names are younger, it was he who institutionalized dishonesty like al-Taqiyya (the lawful lie), Kitman (the lawful half-truth), Hilah (the lawful pretending/circumventing), the use of deceit ("war is deceit" - and "everything" is war), betrayal (f.x. the peace delegation from Khaybar), and even the disuse of oaths (2/225, 5/89, 16/91, 66/2 - and the star case 3/54 (if Allah could cheat, cheating is ok)), which also includes the disuse of words and promises, as they are weaker than oaths = when oaths can be disused, so can words and promises. On top of this it is very clear from the Quran and all other central Islamic books, that Muhammad also liked respect and power and women. Combine these lusts with his acceptance of and personal use of dishonesty - even the gravest kinds: How reliable is that kind of men normally? - and how true and reliable are their never proved claims and tales?

¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤

007 2/5d: "They (the believers*) are on (true) guidance (the Quran*) from their Lord (Allah*) - - -". Wrong - no god has ever sent down a book with so many errors.

008 2/38b: "- - - guidance from Me (Allah*) - - -". This cannot be a reference to the Quran if the god was omniscient - no god uses a book with so much wrong contents as a guidebook. See 7/192a and 16/107 below.

009 2/120c: “The Guidance of Allah (the Quran*) - - -". No omniscient god ever was involved in a book of a quality like the Quran - too much is wrong.

010 2/120d: “The Guidance of Allah (the Quran*) – that is the only Guidance”. No omniscient god ever was involved in a book of a quality like the Quran - too much is wrong. A book with so many mistakes and contradictions, so much invalid logic, and so much inhumanity is not at all a guidance – more likely a misguidance. Also a contradiction of the Bible.

011 2/142e: "He (Allah - in reality here Muhammad and his Quran*) guideth whom He will - - -". As no god included Allah - if he exists - was behind a book of such a miserable level of knowledge and quality (except the linguistics - polished by top brains through some 250 years), it is not Allah who in case is the guide, but the maker of the Quran - be it dark powers or humans, mentally ill or not.

012 2/142f: "He (Allah - in reality here Muhammad and his Quran*) guideth whom He will - - -". A book full of mistakes, included perhaps unbelievable 2ooo points with wrong facts, etc., is no guide book.

013 2/144a: "We (Allah*) see the turning of thy (Muslim's*) face (for guidance) to the heavens (plural and wrong*) - - -". As the Quran is not from Heaven, there is little help in looking that way, if you live according to that book - too much is wrong in the Quran.

014 2/170a: "Follow what Allah hath revealed (= the Quran)." No omniscient god ever revealed a book with that many mistakes, etc. as the Quran.

015 2/185k: "- - - He (Allah*) has guided you (via the Quran)". As the Quran is not from a god, and thus also not from the claimed god Allah, it is not Allah who gives the claimed guidance.

016 2/213b: "- - - Allah sent Messengers (to homo sapience when they were only one tribe(?) (and what about f.x. the Neanderthals or the Denisovans ?) - see 2/213a just above*) - - -". Muhammad claimed that all people through all times all over the world have received prophets/messengers (f.x. 4/47, 16/36, 30/47, 35/24 and indirectly 22/34 and 22/67) - the number 124ooo (= 620 at any time for 5ooo years or 12-15 for 160-200ooo years. No traces from them found. Believe it if you can.) is mentioned in Hadiths. Neither science nor Islam has found any traces from them - nothing older than 610 AD.

017 2/213j: “Allah by His Grace guided - - -". If the Quran is not from Allah, it is not Allah who does the guiding.

018 2/213q: “For Allah guides whom He will to the path that is straight”. According to the Quran this means the road to the Muslim Paradise - see 10/9f below.

019 2/230d: "Such are the limits ordained by Allah - - -". As the Quran with all its errors, etc. is from no god, the claimed limits also are not from a god. Then from whom?

020 2/257d: "- - - from the depths of darkness He (Allah*) will lead them forth into light." Only if the Quran is from a real god - and no real god makes that many mistakes, etc.

021 2/258g: "Nor doth Allah give guidance (via the Quran*) to - - -". As the Quran is not from a god in spite of strong claims (but only claims) from Muhammad and others, the "guidance" via the Quran is not from Allah.

022 2/264c: "And Allah guideth not those who reject faith". But if the Quran is not from him - and no god made a book with that many errors - does he then guide Muslims? Simply no - and what then about a possible next life in case?

023 3/8b: "- - - Thou (Allah*) hast guided us (by means of the Quran*) - - -". No god has guided via the Quran - too much is wrong for any god to be involved in that book.

024 3/30d: "But Allah cautions (via the Quran*) you (to remember) Himself". As no god has sent down a book of a quality like the Quran, it is not Allah who cautions about this - - - if he really is a god.

025 3/73d: "- - - the Guidance (the Quran*) of Allah - - -". No god has had anything to do with the Quran - too much is wrong in it, so much that it is heresy, slander and an insult to blame it on a god, not to mention an omniscient god. Also see 2/2b above.

026 3/86i: "- - - Allah guides not - - -". He cannot guide very many by means of a guidebook like the Quran.

027 3/101f: "Whoever holds firmly to Allah will be shown a way that is straight". If Allah exists. If he in addition is a god. If he is behind what is told in the Quran. And if the Quran in addition tells the full and only truth.

028 3/103a: "- - - the Rope which Allah (stretches out for you (Muslims*)) - - -". The rope is Islam - ok for salvation if Allah exists and is a major god, invalid if the Quran is not from a god - which it clearly is not (no god delivers a book of that quality). What it is if Allah is from the dark forces, is another question.

029 3/138c: "Here (in Allah's Quran*) is - - - a guidance and instruction to those who fear Allah". And a central instruction is: "Wage war for Allah and for Muhammad".

030 4/105e: "- - - as guided by Allah (= the Quran*) - - -". See 7/192a and 16/107 below.

031 4/137d: "- - - Allah will not - - - guide - - -". Allah cannot guide unless he exists.

032 4/175d: "- - - guide them (Muslims*) to Himself (Allah*) - - -". A guide like the Quran can guide no-one to something good - too much is wrong in that book.

033 5/15-16: "- - - a perspicuous Book, Wherewith Allah guideth - - -". No god guides by means of a book full of mistakes - and no good and benevolent god uses a book which in addition has partly immoral and unjust moral code and laws, and neither does a good and benevolent god launch a war, hate, dishonesty, and suppression religion like in the Quran.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

######034 5/35g: “- - - strive with might and main (see 5/35a-b*) in His (Allah’s*) cause - - -”. For us this is one of the most detestable points in the entire Quran and Islam: Fight and steal and rob and mutilate and rape and enslave and hate and murder and lie and get rich and suppress and extort in the name of your god, and as a service to your god - a claimed good and benevolent god!

Some guidance! The same god as Yahweh? Jesus and Muhammad in the same religion? Don't ask silly questions.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

035 5/51g: "- - - Allah guideth not - - -". See 16/107 below".

036 5/67g: “For Allah guideth not - - -”. No, Allah cannot guide many if he tries to use a guidebook as full of mistakes, etc. as the Quran.

037 5/108c: "- - - Allah guideth not - - -". Allah cannot guide anyone unless he exists - and it is noteworthy that not one single case has ever been reported where Allah provably has guided anyone at all.

038 6/71d: "- - - receiving guidance from Allah - - -". Not one proved case of guidance from Allah is registered any place any time. Not one.

039 6/71h: "Allah's guidance is the (only) guidance - - -". Strongly contradicted by the Bible, which claims that the only reliable guidance is from Yahweh. Also see 67/9c below - a strong one. But of course it is ok for Islam to prove - prove - the Bible wrong and the Quran right. But as we say: Prove, not just lose claims and as lose and invalid words like the Quran always use instead of proofs.

040 6/77d: "Unless my (Abram/Abraham*) Lord (Allah according to the Quran*) guide me - - -". As for guide, see 16/107 below.

041 6/77e: "Unless my (Abram/Abraham*) Lord (Allah according to the Quran*) guide me, I (Abram/Abraham*) shall surely be among those who go astray". Not from the Bible.

042 6/88a: "This (the Quran*) is the Guidance of Allah - - -". No god would send down a book with as much wrong like in the Quran as guidance to his followers.

043 6/90a: "Those were the (prophets) who received Allah's guidance - - -". There is documented only one (self proclaimed) prophet who has (or claimed he has) got anything from Allah. Muhammad. And he only (claimed he) got the Quran. The others got it from Yahweh according to the Bible - a piece of information never proved wrong by the Quran - claims yes, proofs no.

044 6/144c: "For Allah guideth not people who do wrong". He guides absolutely no-one unless he exists - a strong probability for that he does not, as the Quran with all its errors, etc. is not from a god.

045 6/149d: "- - - if it had been His Will He could indeed have guided you”. A guide using the Quran with all its errors as a guide-book is not much of a guide.

046 6/155b: “- - - a Book (the Quran*) which we (Allah*) have revealed as a blessing”. A book with many mistakes and invalid and even wrong proofs and facts is no blessing - and is a book with many mistakes and much incitement to hate and war and suppression of other people and of women, a blessing? No.

047 6/161b: "Verily, my (a Muslim*) Lord (Allah*) hath guided me to a Way that is straight (= direction Paradise*)- - -". May be, but not by means of a book with so many errors, and an at too many points immoral moral code like the Quran. It definitely is no proved verity/truth. Also see 16/107 below.

048 7/33e: “The things my (Muhammad’s or Muslims’*) Lord (Allah*) hath indeed forbidden are: - - - trespass against - - - reason - - -". ##########All the places Muhammad uses invalid logic in the Quran are trespasses against reason. The same goes for not a few of all the mistakes in the Quran.

049 7/43b: "- - - Allah, who has guided (via the Quran') us (Muslims*) - - -". No god based his religion on a book full of mistakes, etc. And if the Quran is not from Allah, it does not represent his guidance.

050 7/43d: "- - - the guidance of Allah (= the Quran*) - - -". See 7/43b above and 16/107 below.

051 7/52a: “We (Allah*) had certainly sent unto them a Book (the Quran*), - - -”. The recurring question: Is a book with that many mistakes – wrong facts, contradictions, invalid proofs, unclear language, orthographic and perhaps even religious mistakes - really sent down by a god? Impossible - not to say heresy and an insult against any omnipotent or omniscient god.

053 7/178b: "Whom Allah doth guide - he is on the right path - - -". Even with all those mistakes, etc. in the guide book - the Quran?

054 7/178d: "- - - whom He rejects from His (Allah's) guidance - - -". Here is one of the fundamental differences between the Quran and NT: Allah rejects many from his guidance, yes, he decides before they are even born whether they are to end in Hell or Paradise according to Hadiths. NT never gives in the hope to find again "the lost sheep" - not even "in the eleventh hour".

055 7/186b: "To such (persons*) Allah rejects from His guidance - - -". For comparison: Yahweh/Jesus rejects no-one who is honestly searching - not even heavy sinners in the 11. hour (f.x. Luke. 15/8-10 and 15/11-31, Matt 12-14 and 20/8-13). They have to reject themselves.

056 7/186d: "To such (persons*) Allah rejects from His guidance, there can be no guide - - -". Wrong if other gods - f.x. Yahweh - exist - - - and especially wrong if Allah in addition is a made up god (the facts concerning the Quran does not bode well here).

057 7/193a: "If ye (non-Muslims*) call them (other gods*) to guidance, they will not obey - - -". See 7/192a+b above.

058 9/33e: "It is He (Allah*) Who hath sent his Messenger (Muhammad*) with Guidance - - -". A teaching like Muhammad's with that many mistakes, etc. - just read the Quran - is not much of guidance. No preacher preaching such tales is from a god.

059 9/109b: "And Allah guideth not - - -". He cannot guide unless he exists. - and is something supernatural, black or white (and where does he guide people if he is from the dark forces?)

060 9/115a: "And Allah will not mislead a people after He hath guided them - - -". Allah can neither lead nor mislead unless he exists. - and is something supernatural, black or white (and where does he lead people if he is from the dark forces?)

#061 10/9b: “Those who believe, and work righteousness (included fighting in wars, stealing, raping, and killing*) – their Lord (Allah*) will guide them because of their Faith: beneath them will flow rivers in Gardens of bliss.” The paradise of a primitive warrior from the hot desert - most boring in the long run to say the least of it. Has an omniscient, omnipotent god nothing better to offer? A curiosum: According to Hadiths 2 of "our" rivers - the Nile and the Euphrates - start in Heaven/Paradise.

062 10/35a: "Say (Muhammad*): 'Of your (non-Muslims'*) "partners" (gods*) is there any that can give any guidance towards Truth?' Say: "It is Allah who gives guidance towards Truth (the Quran*)". See 10/34a. Often claimed, never proved. ("A proof is one or more proved facts which can give only one conclusion".)

063 10/35c: “It is (only*) Allah who gives guidance towards the Truth.” But this is contradicted by the fact that he is not reliable – he also can lead you astray according to several verses the Quran. It actually collides with all the verses which tell Allah leads to Heaven whom he wants, and leads astray whom he wants. Or maybe the book only talks about those he wants to guide to Paradise? In NT Yahweh wishes everybody to reach Paradise - in the Quran Allah picks the ones he wishes.

Besides: Is this just an undocumented claim, or a proved fact - hardly anything of any consequence in the Quran is proved - f.x. not even the existence of Allah?

And not to forget: He cannot lead anybody to the Truth by means of a book full of wrong facts and other errors, like the Quran.

064 10/35g: "- - - He (Allah*) who (claims he*) gives guidance to (the claimed*) Truth - - -". Allah's claimed guidance is to be found in the Quran - a book so full of errors, etc., that it at the very best only is partly true, and thus clearly is from no god, not to mention from an omniscient one. (There is a chance, though, that the Quran is from a dressed up something from the dark forces - f.x. it’s partly immoral moral code, its inbuilt prohibition against ethical and moral philosophy, its partly immoral and unjust sharia laws, etc. may indicate this.)

065 10/45i: "- - - true (religious*) guidance". Not possible with a book as full of mistakes as the Quran, and even less so as no book with so many errors, contradictions, etc. is from a god.

066 11/17i: "- - - a witness (Muhammad*) from Himself (Allah*) doth teach - - - a guide and a mercy (the Quran*)." Do read the complete Quran and especially the surahs from Medina - and read it with your brain and your other relevant knowledge engaged, not only your eyes and your wishful thinking. How much of a reliable guide do you find among all the mistakes, contradictions, wrong/invalid logic, etc.? - and how much mercy are you able to find? - real mercy, not glossy words. How much of a teacher of f.x. good morality and of mercy was really Muhammad?! ("Do to others like you want others do to you" - Muhammad was miles and kilomiles from that.)

067 11/17j: "- - - (the teaching of Muhammad is*) a guide and a mercy - - -". Wrong. A teaching based on a book full of mistakes and harsh rules and blood is neither a guide nor a mercy.

068 12/52c: “- - - Allah will never guide - - -”. Not unless he exists, and not unless he has a better guide-book than the Quran with all its mistakes, etc.

069 12/52d: "- - - Allah will never guide the false ones". Muhammad had as slogans "War is deceit" and "War is betrayal" - did Allah guide him in such falseness? And what about al-Taqiyya (the lawful lie) and Kitman (the lawful half-truth) or Hilah (the lawful pretending/circumventing)? - or broken oaths (2/225a, 5/89a+b, 16/91e, 66/2a)? (For some reason or other Islam and its Muslims seldom claim that Islam is the religion of honesty.)

070 13/27i: "- - - He (Allah*) guideth - - -". One cannot do good guiding with a guidebook full of mistakes, contradictions, etc.

071 13/31i: "- - - He (Allah*) could have guided all mankind - - -". Not with a guidebook like the Quran - too much is wrong, included partly horrible moral code. (Actually it may be the moral code which makes many react negatively to the religion and its members - too aggressive, too bloody, too self centered, too haughty and discriminating, etc. There also is reason to react to its acceptance of dishonesty/al-Taqiyya, but most non-Muslims do not know about that part).

072 13/33j "- - - those whom Allah leaves to stray, no one can guide". The Bible contradicts this, at least for believers in Yahweh.

073 14/12d: "Indeed He (Allah*) has guided us (Muslims*) to the Way we (follow)". But going where? - with a guidebook full of mistakes and not from a guide/(god)! (If Allah here should happen to be from the dark forces, then "bonne voyage" - - - and mercy to the followers!)

074 16/9c: "- - - He (Allah*) could have guided all of you (man*)." Not with a guide-book like the Quran - not to the Heaven of a benevolent, goodhearted god.

As essential just here: The "fact" that most people he does not guide, but lets end in Hell according to the Quran, in case proves that he far from is a good and moral and benevolent god.

075 16/36f: "- - - Allah guided - - -". This only is possible if Allah existed. And as he is no god if he was behind the Quran with all its errors: What was he in case, and in what direction did he in case guide them? - this question is especially urgent and interesting if he belonged to the dark forces and just cheated Muhammad.

076 16/37b: "If thou (Muhammad*) is anxious for their (contemporary Muslims'*) guidance, yet Allah guideth not such as He leaves to stray, and there is non to help them". This sentence is a bit helpless, and gives no conclusion to the first part of it. Written by a god?

077 16/37d: "- - - Allah guideth not such as He leaves to stray - - -". In contrast to Yahweh, who guides everyone who honestly wishes so and asks for it.

078 16/37f: "- - - Allah guideth - - -". Allah can guide nobody unless he exists. And if he exists, but belongs to the dark forces, his guidance may be interesting.

079 16/93f: "- - - He (Allah*) guides - - -". Not unless he exists - and if he in case belongs to the dark forces, the use of the Quran with all its mistakes, partly immoral moral code, etc. as a guide-book may be understandable.

080 16/102k: “- - - revelations from thy Lord (Allah*) in Truth, in order to strengthen those who believe, and as a Guide and Glad Tidings to Muslims”. What kind of glad tidings can be built on at least to a large part mistaken and/or valueless statements and as wrong facts? It is bad if Islam really believes everything - that means they are too blind - or blinded - to see even the most obvious mistakes (but this is normal for strong believers in all religions - Muslims are very typical here). But it is much worse if (some of) the leaders and learned men/teachers see the mistakes and bluff their audiences. And not least: If all the mistakes means that Islam is a made up religion - such religions do happen - and blocks the way for its (un)believers to a true religion (if such one exists), what then? Besides: Is it permission to steal and rob and rape and take slaves that are “glad tidings”? – fighting, women, and looting - and indirectly but clearly also dishonesty in other forms - are very central in the Quran.

081 16/104c: "- - - Allah will not guide them (non-Muslims*) - - -". It is difficult to guide anyone with a guide-book like the Quran - lots of mistakes and a partly deplorable moral code. Also he cannot guide if he does not exist.

082 16/107b: "- - - Allah will not guide those who reject Faith". But is he able to guide at all?

  1. There has been no proof for even Allah's existence.
  2. There has been no proof for that he in case was/is a god.
  3. There has been no proof for his claimed power.
  4. There has been no proof for that he ever guided anyone, included Muhammad.
  5. There has been no proof for his claimed connection to Muhammad.
  6. There has been no proof for his claimed benevolence. On the contrary he is a god of war and discrimination, if he exists.
  7. There are solid proofs for that he has no connection to the Quran - no god would deliver that quality "guide-book" - unbelievable 3ooo+ errors, etc. + low quality literature.
  8. There are solid proofs for lots of mistakes, etc. (3ooo+) in the Quran = no reliable "guide-book".
  9. There are solid proofs for hundreds of points with wrong facts in the Quran.
  10. The many errors in the Quran are 100% proof for that the book is not from any god.
  11. There are solid proofs for that the Bible is not falsified - science + for OT Jesus/the Qumran scrolls, and not least Islam, who has found not one proved falsification in the entire Bible. There are some errors also in the Bible, but neither science nor Islam has found even one proved falsification.
  12. The Quran's partly immoral moral code is a solid proof for that no good or benevolent god is involved.
  13. The many and fundamental differences in Yahweh's and Allah's teachings, moral codes, etc. are 100% and more proofs for that the two are not the same god - and Jesus and Muhammad not in the same religion.
  14. The surahs from Medina are solid proofs for that Islam is a religion of war, dishonesty, and apartheid.

083 16/121d: "- - - Allah - - - guided him (Abraham*) - - -". Even if we omit the likeliness for that Allah was not involved: Can Allah guide anyone at all? - he has never proved so.

084 17/97d: "- - - Allah guides - - -". If he exists - and if the Quran is true at least on that point.

085 18/17c: "- - - he whom Allah guides, is rightly guided - - -". The only guidance Allah is claimed to have sent, is the Quran. With that many mistakes, contradictions, etc, it is no reliable guide, and this is made even more obvious by the fact that a book of such a quality is not from any god.

086 18/24a: "- - - the Lord (here claimed to be Allah*) will guide - - -". The only guide Allah is claimed to have produced, it the Quran - and a book with that many mistakes, etc. is no reliable guide.

087 19/58b: "- - - those (Jewish prophets*) whom We (Allah*) guided - - -". As Allah and Yahweh are not the same god - too much is different of the fundamental elements of the teachings - Allah was not involved with the Jewish prophets according to the Bible.

088 19/76a: "- - - Allah doth advance in guidance those who seek guidance - - -". The old fact: Not possible unless Allah exists and in addition is a god.

089 20/48b: "Verily it has been revealed to us (Moses and Aaron*) that the Penalty (awaits) those who reject (guidance (= Islam*)) and turn away". In the Bible there is no religious debate - only the demand to let the Jews go.

090 20/123c: "- - - My (Allah's*) Guidance - - -." If here is meant the Quran, there is not much guidance in a book with that much mistakes, contradictions, invalid logic, etc.

091 22/16d: "- - - Allah doth guide whom He will". Let us in case hope he does not use the Quran with all its errors and even some lies as a guide-book.

092 22/16f: “- - - Allah doth guide whom He will.” Whereas Yahweh and NT guides whoever who wants strongly enough to qualify - and offers guidance also too all the others. The same god?

093 22/37d: "- - - His (Allah's*) Guidance - - -". Allah can guide nobody unless he exists and is a god, none of which was ever proved. He also cannot safely guide anybody by means of a guidebook as full of errors, wrong facts, etc. as the Quran.

094 22/54h: “- - - Allah is the Guide of those who believe - - -". Allah cannot be the guide of anyone, unless he exists and is a god. Well, he can be a guide even if he belongs to the dark forces (or simply is a mental pagan and manmade idol), but what kind of a guide in case?

095 22/54i: “- - - Allah (the Quran*) is the Guide of those who believe, to the Straight Way.” Wrong – a book with that many mistakes, twisted facts/logic, etc. - and even at least some lies - is not representing a straight way, at least not to Paradise.

096 23/27c: "- - - Our (Allah's*) guidance - - -". According to the Bible the involved god was Yahweh, not Allah.

097 23/110a: "- - - My (Allah's*) Message (the Quran*) - - -". The Quran may well be Allah's message, but in that case he is no omniscient god - too much is wrong in the book.

098 24/35c: "Allah doth guide whom He will to his light". But a black point is that he also denies Paradise for whom he will - something he decides already 5 months before you are born according to Hadiths, and you have no chance to change his mind and his Plan according to the Quran - even if you try to do your very best to be a good Muslim, Allah will block the road to Paradise for you a little before you are qualified, if you are destined for Hell - this according to Hadiths.

099 24/35d: "Allah doth guide whom He will to his light". This also differs greatly from the Bible: Allah guides whom he wants - Yahweh guides absolutely everybody who wants strongly enough to qualify (free will for man is real in the Bible, and everybody can choose) according to the Bible.

Besides: He cannot guide anybody to "the light" unless he exists and is a god. Not to mention: Where does he guide people if he exists, but are from the dark forces? - too many harsh points for comfort may indicate this, and Muhammad would have no chance to see the difference if Iblis/the Devil dressed up like Gabriel and pretended to be from a god.

100 24/46d: "- - - Allah guides - - -". See 2/2b above.

101 25/31c: "- - - but enough is thy (Muhammad's/Muslims'*) Lord (Allah*) to guide and to help." There has not in 1400 years been even one documented case of guidance or help from Allah. Lots of claims, but not one documented case.

102 28/49b: “Then bring ye (non-Muslims*) a Book (the Quran*) from Allah, which is a better Guide - - -“. A book that full of wrong facts, twisted arguments, contradictions, invalid statements and as invalid logic is no good guide for anyone.

103 28/50c: "- - - guidance from Allah (the Quran and Muhammad*) - - -". There is not much reliable guidance in a guide-book full of mistakes. And what about a guide believing in al-Taqiyya (the lawful lie), Kitman (the lawful half-truth), etc., deception ("war is deceit" - and everything is jihad), and breaking his word/promise/oath?

104 28/50f: "For Allah guides not people given to wrongdoing." One may ask who - if anyone - then guided the Muslims the next centuries? - you find much wrongdoing and worse in Islamic history during that period. Cfr. "do to others like you want others do to you".

105 28/56b: "- - - but Allah guides whom He wills". Whereas Yahweh according to NT guides all and everybody who wishes to be guided (f.x. Luke 15/8-10 + 15/11-31 and Matt 18/12-14 + 20/8-13). Just and only here is such a fundamental abyss between the ways Allah and Yahweh thinks and acts (Yahweh guides anyone who wish and who lives accordingly), that this alone is a 110% proof for that they were not the same god, even if there had not been other differences - but there are many.

106 28/85e: "My Lord (Allah*) knows best who it is that brings true guidance (Muhammad/good Muslims*), and who (non-Muslims*/bad Muslims*) is in manifest error". See 2/233h above.

107 28/85f: "My Lord (Allah*) knows best who it is that brings true guidance (Muhammad/good Muslim*), and who (non-Muslim*/bad Muslim*) is in manifest error". Once more back to the old fact: Only if Allah exists and in addition is something supernatural - white or dark.

108 29/69c: "- - - We (Allah*) will certainly guide - - -". Anyone using the Quran as a guidebook, is not a reliable guide - too much is wrong, and for religious guidance: A book with so many errors is not from a god.

109 30/29g: "But who will guide those whom Allah leaves astray?" One more difference between Islam and Christianity: Allah leaves people astray, and he even makes it difficult or impossible for many to find again or even find the road to Heaven - for some he according to the Hadiths blocks it already 5 months before they are born. God/Yahweh according to Jesus and NT always wants to welcome them back - even the worst ones - if there is honest regret. Read f.x. about "the lost sheep" (f.x. Matt. 18/12-14) and "the 11. hour" (f. ex. Matt. 20/1-16).

110 31/5d: "- - - (true) guidance (the Quran*) from their (Muslims'*) Lord (Allah*) - - -". No book with that much wrong is from a god.

111 32/13b: “If We (Allah*) had so willed, We could certainly have brought every soul its true guidance - - -”. This only could be true if Allah exists and is a god.

#112 32/13f: “If We (Allah*) so willed, We could certainly have brought every soul its true guidance: but the Word from Me will come true, ‘I will fill Hell with Jinns and men all together’”. One thought: May be it is true Allah has arranged also Hell like a number of Muslim scholars believe (their logic is that Hell could not exist without Allah's permission, if Allah is omnipotent). Another thought: No matter if he has or not – as long as he wants to fill Hell with living beings, he is no benevolent god. Yet another thought: Can the Quran be explained by that the god permitted f.x. a devil (Iblis?) to make a "holy" book to deceive more humans, on the condition that it contained so much wrong that intelligent persons had a fair chance to see the trap?

113 32/23e: (YA3656): "Moses had, revealed to him, a Law, a sharia (!*), which was to guide his people in all practical affairs of their life. Jesus, after him, was also inspired by Allah (by Yahweh according to the Bible*): but his Injil or Gospel contained only general principles and not a Code (here in the meaning Law) or sharia. The Prophet (Muhammad*) was the next one to have a sharia - - -". What the honorable Abdullah Yusuf Ali "fails" to mention is that the laws and rules in the Bible, and especially so the "general principles" given by Jesus, are so different - and so fundamentally different - from the ones in the Quran, that they are not from the same god, not unless he is mentally very ill.

114 32/24c: "- - - (the Jews were given*) guidance under Our (Allah's) command - - -". Contradicted by the Bible, which tells that the involved god was Yahweh, not Allah. Also see 67/9c below - a strong one. But of course it is ok for Islam to prove - prove - the Bible wrong and the Quran right. But as we say: Prove, not just lose claims and as lose and invalid words like the Quran always use instead of proofs.

115 35/8j: "For Allah leaves to stray whom He Wills, and guides whom He wills". Once more one of the abysses between the Quran and NT: Allah picks whom he wants for salvation, Yahweh saves absolutely everyone who wants and qualifies - even up to the last moment, if there is honest regret and belief. The same god? Jesus and Muhammad in the same religion? Impossible.

116 37/118a: "- - - We (Allah*) guided - - -". According to the Bible this was done by Yahweh.

117 38/29a: “- - - a Book (the Quran*) which We (Allah*) have sent down - - -”. Lots of mistakes, lots of contradictions, lots of invalid “signs” and “proofs”, and lots and lots of not documented/not proved claims and statements, all of which had to be seen through sooner or later - are those the hallmarks of an omniscient god? Normally they are hallmarks of cheats, deceivers and swindlers. No god sent it.

118 38/29b: “Here is a Book (the Quran*) which We (Allah*) have sent down unto thee (Muhammad*) - - -". No god ever sent down what Muhammad did teach - too much was and is wrong in the texts. And too much of the contents are too harsh and immoral for that the maker can have been someone or something good or benevolent.

119 39/3f: "- - - Allah guides not - - -". See 16/107 above.

120 39/18f: "- - - Allah has guided - - -". He cannot do good guiding by means of a guide-book full of mistakes, etc.

121 39/23h: "He (Allah*) guides therewith whom He pleases - - -". Here is one of the many fundamental differences between Yahweh and Allah: NT tells about a god trying to save as many as possible - if they want and are able to qualify or honestly repent, they go to Paradise. The Quran tells about a god who "guides - - - whom He pleases" and blocks the road for the others. One more indication- not to say proof - for that Yahweh and Allah are not the same god. Also see 39/23j below.

##122 39/37b: "And such as Allah doth guide there can be none to lead astray". There is no need to lead them astray - following especially the surahs from Medina they already are far astray compared to normal codes of conduct and moral. Compare to "do unto others like you want others to do unto you" and see for yourself.

123 39/57a: "- - - if only Allah had guided me (a non-Muslim) - - -". Allah cannot guide anyone unless he exists and in addition is a god. There has been not one proved case of guidance from Allah in 1400 years and more - a lot of claims, but not one proved case (the best proof for this is Islam's silence on this point).

124 40/28k: "- - - Allah guides not one who transgresses and lies!" The thought provoking question is: Does he guide anyone at all? - no such case is ever proved.

It is clear from the Quran and from Hadiths that Muhammad used lies as working tools - and he transgressed on very many the last 10 years of his life. Then this verse thus means he was not guided by Allah. (Also clear from the fact that the Quran and all its mistakes is not from any god.)

125 40/33d: "- - - any whom Allah leaves to stray, there is none to guide". See 40/33b above.

126 41/17c: "- - - We (Allah*) gave them Guidance - - -". If the guidance was similar to in the Quran, it was doubtful guidance in case - fit mainly for robber and war groups, tribes or nations.

127 42/13k: "Allah chooses to Himself those whom He pleases, and guides to Himself - - -". The old fact: Possible - possible - only if he exists and is something supernatural, white or dark.

128 42/13m: "- - - (Allah*) guides - - -". Not possible by means of a book with so much wrong facts and immoral moral like in the Quran - that is to say: It is possible, but where does then the "trip" end?

129 42/52j: "- - - wherewith We (Allah*) guide such of Our servants as We will - - -". Once more: Allah can guide - for good or bad - nobody unless he exists and is something supernatural.

130 42/52k: "- - - wherewith We (Allah*) guide such of Our servants as We will - - -". Compare this to f.x. "the lost sheep" (Matt. 18/12-14). The same god?

131 43/27b: "- - - He (Allah*) will certainly guide me (Abraham*) - - -". Allah could guide nobody unless he existed and was something supernatural.

132 43/49c: "- - - for we (Pharaoh Ramses II*) shall truly accept guidance (from Allah*)". One thing is that nothing like this is in the Bible. Another thing is: How likely is it that Ramses II - probably the mightiest Pharaoh ever - said things like this about the god of a bunch of slaves?

133 43/49d: "- - - for we (Pharaoh Ramses II*) shall truly (definitely not a proved truth - only a not proved claim*) accept guidance (accept Allah/Islam*)". In the Bible he only promised to let the Jews go, not to mention that there was no religious quarrel. As the Quran is not from any god - too many mistakes, etc. - from where did Muhammad get this version? And have Muslims found a single trace of Islam in Egypt or anywhere else older than 610 AD? - some 2ooo years after this is said to have happened. Also see 43/52s below.

134 45/23c: "- - - after Allah (has withdrawn guidance) - - -". If Allah does not exist or is no god, there is no guidance to withdraw. And even if he should happen to exist, there is not much true guidance to find in his guidebook - too much is wrong there.

135 46/10g: "- - - Allah guides not a people unjust". Allah is no good guide for anyone if his guidebook is the Quran with all its errors, etc.

136 48/2e: "- - - (Allah will*) guide thee (Muhammad*) - - -". If Allah guided Muhammad, Allah for one thing is not omniscient - too many mistakes, etc. in his guidebook. For another he was not clairvoyant, which he should be if he was like described in the Quran - he had to abrogate many points of his teaching, and also changed it radically from rather peaceful to one of war, hate and central elements of dishonesty around and after 622 - 624 AD. For a third he was no good and benevolent god - much of what Muhammad did, was from inhuman to real horror. And finally: Allah in case is a god of terror and war.

137 48/28c: “It is He (Allah*) Who has sent His Messenger (Muhammad*) with Guidance - - -”. There is not much guidance in a teaching based on a book with that many mistakes and littered with hallmarks of a cheat and deceiver (lose statements and invalid “signs” and “proofs”).

138 49/17b: "- - - Allah has conferred a favor upon you (Muslims*) that He has guided you to the Faith - - -". Like in all other religions saying similar things, it only is true that it is a favor, if the teachings are true and from a god.

139 49/17c: "- - - Allah has conferred a favor upon you (Muslims*) that He has guided you to the Faith - - -". A harsh war religion may not be a favor to its followers no matter if it is true - and till now there never was a war religion which proved itself true - sometimes strong, but never a proof for that there was a god behind it.

140 53/30c: "- - - (Allah*) knoweth best those who stray from His Path, and He knoweth best those who receive guidance". See 2/233h above.

141 57/9g: "- - - He (Allah*) may lead you (by means of the Quran*) from the depths of Darkness into the light". No book with so much wrong and with such a large part of its moral code immoral and brutal, can lead anyone into real light - especially as f.x. all the mistakes prove that the texts are not from any god.

142 61/5e: "- - - Allah guides not - - -". Allah cannot guide anyone unless he exists and is something supernatural.

143 61/7c: "And Allah guides not those who do wrong". Allah cannot guide anyone very well, as long as he uses a guidebook full of mistakes and with a partly immoral moral code.

##144 61/9b: “It is He (Allah*) Who has sent His Messenger (Muhammad*) with Guidance - - -”. A teaching based on a book containing unbelievable perhaps 3ooo+ mistakes, lose statements, contradictions, invalid “signs” and “proofs” + at least some (50+ ?) clear lies, and statements telling that Muhammad did not respect even his oaths too much, is not much of a guidance.

145 62/5h: "- - - Allah guides not - - -". Allah can guide nobody unless he exists - and if he uses the Quran with all its errors, what is the value of such guiding?.

146 64/11c: "- - - (Allah) guides - - -". If he guides according to the Quran, he is no good guide - too much is wrong and parts of the moral code are horrible (compare it to "do to others like you want others do to you" and weep - or laugh at Islam's claim of being the pinnacle of good moral).

147 68/7d: "- - - He (Allah*) knoweth best those who receive (true) Guidance". Why then does he have to test them by sending them to war, etc. to kill, murder, become invalids or be killed, etc.?

148 68/7f: "- - - (true) Guidance". His(?) guidebook is the Quran, and there is not much real guidance - not to mention true guidance - in a book full of mistakes, etc, a partly immoral moral code, etc., and a book which itself proves it is not from a god./p>

##149 74/31m: "Thus doth Allah - - - guide whom He pleaseth - - -". Another (see 74/31k just above) big difference between the Quran and NT: Allah guides whom he pleases, Yahweh everyone who wishes and manages to qualify. One more indication for that Yahweh and Allah are not the same god.

150 76/3a: "We (Allah*) showed him (man) the Way - - -". Not unless Allah exists.

151 93/7: "- - - He (Allah/the Quran*) gave thee (Muslim*) guidance". Wrong - there is not much guidance in a book full of mistakes, etc.

151 comments. Sub-total = 7028 + 151 = 7179.


>>> Go to  Next Chapter

>>> Go to  Previous Chapter

This work was upload with assistance of M. A. Khan, editor of islam-watch.org and the author of "Islamic Jihad: A Legacy of Forced Conversion, Imperialism, and Slavery".